7 min read

A Worked Site Analysis From Visit to Five Design Moves

Eighteen metres of frontage. Forty-two deep. A tired 1960s bungalow sat in the middle of it, a mature oak on the north boundary with a Tree Preservation Order attached, and a client who wants a four-bedroom replacement house with a view down the garden.

That's the plot this article carries end to end — the visit, the desk check, the five findings that survived editing, and the exact thing each finding moved in the drawings. Plus the sheets that went in the bin, because the binning is the part nobody ever shows you. It's a composite plot, the sort that lands on a Part 1 assistant's desk in month two, but every constraint on it is one you will meet.

ArchAdemia Toolkit

Site Analysis

See the toolkit

ArchAdemia Toolkit

Site Analysis

AI-powered site analysis with image recognition and design guidance

See the toolkit

Two Hours on Site, and What Actually Got Written Down

The visit produced about forty photographs and three pages of scribble. The useful half was all the same kind of thing: measurements of stuff you will later have to design against.

Every boundary condition, edge by edge — 1.8m close-boarded fence south, 900mm brick wall and the oak north, a hedge on a bank to the rear, low wall and a dropped kerb to the street. The neighbour's windows on the shared side, their rough cill heights, and which rooms they obviously serve. Where the ground falls, paced and eyeballed before the measured survey arrived. The width of the carriageway and where cars were actually parked at 8:40am on a Tuesday. A long strip of darker, mossier grass along the rear fence that only makes sense if water sits there.

Times written on every photo, because a photo of a flank wall at 11am and the same wall at 4pm are two different pieces of evidence.

The street got walked as far as the junction in both directions, photographing every front elevation. Not for a vernacular study — for the planning officer, who will want to know whether a two-storey house is the odd one out here. It isn't: four of the eleven houses on this side are already two storeys.

The rest of the notes were atmosphere. Birdsong, the smell of someone's bonfire, "nice sense of enclosure". All of it was later deleted.

Six Desk Searches, Four Useful Answers

Desk work on a plot this size is an afternoon, not a week. What got checked, and what came back:

  • The council's online planning register, for the whole street. Two approvals for two-storey rear extensions, and one refusal at number 9 — refused on overlooking of the neighbouring rear garden. That refusal was worth more than every other source combined.
  • The TPO register. Oak confirmed, order from the 1990s, no exemptions.
  • The Environment Agency flood maps and the lead local flood authority's surface water mapping. Not in a fluvial flood zone. Surface water mapping shows a low-risk ponding strip along the rear boundary — which matches the mossy grass.
  • The British Geological Survey viewer. London Clay. Shrinkable, and the oak is forty years older than any new foundation.
  • The local plan and the council's residential design SPD. Separation distances, a version of the 45-degree test from neighbouring habitable-room windows, and parking standards. Every authority's SPD is different; read yours rather than the one you memorised in second year.
  • Historic OS mapping. Field, field, field, bungalow. Nothing. This one produced no finding and took eleven minutes, which is the right amount of time to spend proving a negative.

The Five That Survived

Each one is an observation, the evidence that made it undeniable, and the dimension it changed. If a finding can't produce that third part, it isn't a finding — it's a diagram.

Finding 1 — The oak owns the north third of the plot. Stem measured roughly 620mm in diameter at 1.5m above ground. BS 5837 calculates the root protection area for a single-stem tree at twelve times the stem diameter, which puts a radius of about 7.4m around that trunk, and that circle swallows the whole north-west corner including the obvious spot for a garage.

Design move: footprint shifted 5.5m south of the north boundary. The detached garage was deleted entirely and replaced with two parking spaces on the existing hardstanding, which has the side benefit of not excavating foundations in shrinkable clay inside the rooting zone of a protected tree.

Finding 2 — Number 9's rear extension changes what height means here. The south neighbour has a single-storey rear extension with a kitchen window 4.2m from the shared boundary. Run the SPD's 45-degree line from that window and the first floor of the obvious L-shaped plan sits straight through it.

Design move: the first floor was pulled back 2.4m from the rear building line on the south side only, and the main ridge turned through 90° to run parallel with the boundary rather than across it. Ridge height as seen from next door dropped by roughly 900mm. The house got a longer, lower back than the client first imagined, and it got through.

Finding 3 — The existing drive is in the worst possible place. It sits on the inside of a shallow bend, with residents' cars parked up to within a few metres of the dropped kerb most of the day. Manual for Streets puts stopping sight distance at a 30mph design speed at around 43m, and you cannot see that far out of this access with two cars parked where they always are.

Design move: the access relocated 9m north to the far end of the frontage, where the sightline opens up. That decision moved the front door to the other end of the plan, which swapped the hall and the kitchen, which is why the kitchen ended up facing the street. A highways constraint rearranged the ground floor. That is normal.

Finding 4 — The best view out is also a view into someone's patio. From the proposed first-floor landing, the view down the garden is lovely. It is also a view across 9.4m into the south neighbour's seating area, which is exactly what killed the application at number 9.

Design move: the landing window omitted and replaced with a rooflight over the stair. The flank glazing at ground level became a clerestory strip at 1.9m. One window deleted, one refusal avoided — and the refusal next door is cited in the statement, by reference, so the officer knows we read it.

Finding 5 — The garden drains towards the house. Ground falls roughly 700mm from the rear hedge bank to the back wall of the bungalow. Clay beneath. A ponding strip on the LLFA mapping. The existing owner had dug a gravel trench along the rear wall, which is the universal signal that a building has a water problem its owner has stopped mentioning.

Design move: finished floor level set 225mm above existing ground at the rear, a filter trench and shallow swale along the back boundary, and the client's sunken terrace deleted before it ever got drawn. Deleting an idea at analysis stage is cheaper than deleting it at technical design.

a single-sheet constraints plan of a suburban plot showing the oak's root protection circle, 45-degree overlooking lines from a neighbour's window, a visibility

The Cut Pile

What didn't make it, and why. This list is longer than the one above, and on a good job it always is.

The sun path diagram, all twelve months of it, reduced to one sentence: the rear garden is south-west facing and the oak shades the north-west corner until mid-afternoon in summer. A wind rose — cut, because nothing in the design changed because of it. A figure-ground of the surrounding 1km — cut, because this is one house on an established suburban street and no officer is being persuaded by urban grain. The 400m walking-distance circle with the bus stop in it — cut, except as a single line in the planning statement where it earns its keep. Noise observations — cut. Historic mapping — cut, as above, having proved nothing. The street-elevation photo study survived, but as a single strip of six photographs rather than six pages.

And the atmosphere notes. All of them. "Pleasant sense of enclosure" has never moved a dimension in the history of architecture.

The rule we teach for this edit is brutal and simple: for every sheet, write the design move it caused in the margin. If the margin is empty after ninety seconds, the sheet goes. Not into an appendix — appendices are where cowards hide their cut pile. Into the bin.

When You Know You're Finished

The finished document for this plot ran to eight A3 pages: a location and context page, one constraints plan, the five findings at roughly a page each with the design move stated in the same breath, and a half-page of what was checked and found irrelevant. That last page is the one that earns trust, because it tells a reader you looked rather than guessed.

For a one-house application, a Design and Access Statement isn't automatically required — the Development Management Procedure Order sets out when one is, broadly major development and smaller schemes in conservation areas — but the analysis does its work either way, as the opening section of the planning statement. The mechanics of writing it up for three different readers, and how the captions carry the argument, are a separate job; we covered those in How to Write a Site Analysis Report People Actually Read.

Here is the test we use for completion, and it has nothing to do with page count. Hand the analysis to someone who has never seen the site and ask them where the front door goes and why. If they can tell you, and their reasons are your reasons, stop. You're done.

An analysis isn't finished when you run out of layers to draw. It's finished when the drawings would be wrong without it.

Written by

Kenny McNaughton

Managing Director, ArchAdemia

About the team

ArchAdemia Toolkit

Site Analysis

ArchAdemia members can do this in minutes with the toolkit below.

New guides by email. Course releases, free templates and guides, and software tips worth stealing. One click to unsubscribe.